The Dunning–Kruger Effect and CBT
Beyond Mere Stupidity
Imagine rubbing lemon juice on your face and believing you are now invisible to cameras. That your face can’t be recorded by electronic devices. That you can rob a bank and not get caught. Well, you probably never imagined that because it is too absurd. This might be a hilarious premise for a comedy movie script, but definitely not in real life.
However, that’s precisely what happened on January 6, 1995. Two men named McArthur Wheeler and Clifton Earl Johnson committed armed robberies at two Greater Pittsburgh banks. Rather than disguising themselves, they bizarrely covered their faces in lemon juice, convinced it would render them invisible to security cameras. Johnson was apprehended a few days later, while Wheeler was identified in surveillance photos and arrested in April. Both individuals were sentenced to multiple years in jail. When questioned why they did that, Wheeler said, "But I wore the juice!"
Why did they do that? Wheeler knew about lemon juice functioning as invisible ink. In his twisted logic, applying lemon juice to his face would render it invisible to cameras, as it renders writings invisible to the naked eye. Before the heists, he experimented with this idea, applying juice to his face and taking a Polaroid selfie. The outcome was a blank space where his face should have been! That happened because he probably wasn’t able to operate a Polaroid camera properly; nobody knows exactly what happened. The only drawback in his plans, according to him, was that the lemon juice caused intense stinging in his eyes, severely impairing his vision.
This incident caught the attention of social psychologists David Dunning and Justin Kruger, who were curious to understand what could lead people to believe in such a thing. Consequently, they conducted studies that would become known as the Dunning-Kruger effect.
The Dunning-Kruger effect
It is a cognitive bias where individuals with limited knowledge or expertise in a specific area tend to overestimate their abilities. Essentially, they lack the metacognitive ability to recognize their own incompetence. Meaning, they don’t know that they don’t know. This can lead them to believe they're more skilled or knowledgeable than they actually are, which can result in painful situations for them and, unfortunately, for others. And when I say them, I mean all of us, as we can all fall victim to this distorted cognitive process. I find it an intriguing concept that sheds light on how our perception of our own competence can sometimes be disconnected from reality and illustrates how individuals with limited expertise can mistakenly believe they excel in a particular field.
To understand that, Dunning and Kruger conducted a study published in 1999, "Unskilled and Unaware of It: How Difficulties in Recognizing One’s Own Incompetence Lead to Inflated Self-Assessments." This aimed to investigate the relationship between competence and self-assessment in various domains. They used tests in humor, grammar, and logic to assess participants' actual abilities and then compared these scores to participants' self-assessments.
Participants were asked to perform tasks in these domains and then estimate their performance compared to others. Interestingly, those who performed poorly consistently overestimated their abilities significantly. This trend was observed across the different domains tested. Moreover, those who performed well tended to underestimate their own abilities, assuming that others had similar levels of expertise.
The studies revealed a key insight: individuals with lower ability in a particular area were less accurate in assessing their own performance and tended to overestimate their competence. This led to the formulation of the Dunning-Kruger effect, highlighting the disconnect between actual competence and individuals' perceptions of their competence.
But don’t mistake the Dunning-Kruger effect for stupidity; it is more complex than that.
Good old Socrates
Socrates once famously said, "I know that I know nothing." This statement reflects Socrates' recognition of his own ignorance, challenging oneself through introspection, and acknowledging the vastness of knowledge yet to be acquired. This challenging task involves significant higher brain functioning. Socrates believed that true wisdom comes from acknowledging the limitations of one's knowledge and understanding that there's always more to learn. This sentiment aligns with the concept underlying the Dunning-Kruger effect, emphasizing the importance of recognizing one's limitations to genuinely advance knowledge and understanding. However, that doesn’t come easily, as our reasoning process isn't purely rational; it involves emotional processes. When we become too certain about our beliefs, we might act confidently, yet irrationally.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)
CBT could aid in addressing the Dunning-Kruger effect by assisting individuals in evaluating their thoughts and emotional processes.
Consider an individual who consistently struggles with managing their finances due to poor decision-making. They might frequently overspend, accumulating debt, yet believe they are exceptionally skilled at handling money. When confronted with their financial troubles, they might react defensively, thinking, 'I've got everything under control. I'm great with money.' The constant cognitive dissonance can even create defense mechanisms to protect this belief.
This person could hold some hard-to-change beliefs to justify their behavior, such as:
"I'm a natural risk-taker; that's how successful people handle money." This fantasy thought could lead them to justify impulsive or high-risk spending behavior as a sign of their financial expertise, rather than acknowledging the consequences.
"I've always managed to get by; I must be doing something right." They might use past instances of barely managing financially as evidence that they are adept at handling money, overlooking the underlying instability and strain it causes.
"I just need this one big purchase to set everything straight." Believing that a significant purchase or investment will miraculously solve their financial woes, they might justify extravagant spending, neglecting the ongoing issues.
"I deserve the best; I work hard for it." This thought could lead them to overspend on luxuries or unnecessary items, justifying it as a reward for their hard work without considering the long-term financial repercussions.
"I'll figure it out eventually; it's not that bad." Minimizing the severity of their financial situation, they might downplay the impact of their decisions and procrastinate in taking necessary steps towards financial responsibility.
Through the application of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), this person begins to examine their thought process. They gradually recognize that their overspending and debt accumulation don't align with their belief in financial expertise. By challenging these beliefs and examining their behaviors more objectively, they start to realize the gaps in their financial knowledge and decision-making. One effective technique I encourage them to exercise on these particular scenarios is seeking evidence. It is one of the signature techniques of CBT. It consists of investigating if the thoughts actually align with reality, like the work of a detective putting the pieces of a puzzle together, or a lawyer trying to win a case in court.
As CBT sessions progress, they learn to confront their misconceptions and evaluate their financial situation more accurately. This process helps reduce their overestimation of financial competence and encourages a more realistic assessment of their financial management skills.
Conclusion
The Dunning-Kruger effect highlights a fascinating cognitive bias wherein individuals with limited abilities in a particular domain tend to overestimate their competence. Conversely, those with higher expertise may underestimate their abilities. This insight underscores the importance of self-awareness, humility, and continuous learning. Recognizing one's limitations is the first step towards genuine competence and growth, emphasizing the value of accurate self-assessment in various facets of life. In other words, aspire to be more like Socrates than the two bank robbers.
Images
Image by rawpixel.com on Freepik.